Masking Tape

Masking Tapes

Adhesive Properties

Oh the horors of having tape pull up the paint below

Seemed like a simple enough project to paint the deck on my boat. Add some non-skid and repair several years of little cracks where the old non-skid was coming off. It turned into the project from hell when the masking tape pulled off the paint below. In spots it did not pull anything off. In spots it pulled off my fresh paint. In other spots it pulled off 10 years of paint leaving rather deep ridges. In one spot it pulled off all the paint, 60 years worth, all the way to the base cloth. This was a low stick tape. It was not as low stick as the tape I once used so I started looking for more of that tape. I could not find it but I did find a list of tapes and how sticky they are. This is not very easy to find so I thought I would share the results of the several hours I spent online finding this information.

I started with the tapes commonly available in the local stores, then added a couple more for comparison. The tapes are:

Standard Blue Multi Purpose 3M-2090
3M Blue Advanced Tape 3M-2080
3M Blue Advanced but with the green lettering 3M-2093
3M-06526 percision masking tape
Frog Tape, standard
Frog Tape Delicate Surfaces
Sure Tape CP 29 Purple
3m 2460 Ultimate Paint Edge
3M-2070 Save-Release - discontinued

The last three are not commonly available with the last one not available at all. It is still listed on Amazon, but you cannot buy it. Left off t his list is a tape that you can get at West Marine called 3M Scotch Performance Masking Tape #233. It has an adhesion of 38 so it is getting close to Duct Tape which is 55. I also left off the ever present Green Tape, 3M-256, which has an adhesion of 25, more than the standard blue tape. That said, when I say standard blue tape I mean the blue tape that comes nicely wrapped up. The real standard blue tape is 2750 and has an adhesive rating of 38.

By the way, it was the 3M 2480 that pulled off the paint. I did not find it easy release like I remember it from the last time I used it.

The graph below shows the adhesion and thickness of these tapes. The thickness may have an influence on the look of the edge so I included it. Most tapes are similar though. I included the strength of the tape as getting tape off is sometimes an issue.

It is too bad that the 3M-2070 is not available but it really was not very sticky. It was difficult to get it to stick. It is similar to Post-It. Speaking of Post-It, they do make Post-It tape but I could not find the specifications and do not know if it works with paint. At the other end, I found Duct Tape at 55 ounces per inch of width, which is the unit of measure in the graph. The thickness is in mills.

Data

Conslusion

Based on this research, I have ordered some of the CP-28 tape. I look forward to testing some tape that is not 3M because of the bad experience I just had. It is $12 a roll for the 1 inch width. More expensive than the Home Depot tapes but using the Advanced 3M tape cost me 2 full days labor to sand down the craters and apply two new coats. The 2460 was tempting but it is much more expensive because of the shipping costs as it is not Prime. If I can find a local source for it I will definitely give it a try. The Post-It tape was 2 inches wide and 36 yards instead of 60 yards. I would have to cut the roll in half on a talbe saw to make it reasonable to use. As I said, I am unsure if will even work as painters tape. The 2070 was low tack but in reality margional as painters tape because it just did not stick.

Please read website Cookie, Privacy, and Disclamers by clicking HERE. To contact me click HERE. For my YouTube page click HERE